Sunday, October 17, 2010

Binging...is this normal

So, I am sticking to the 3FatChicks website for the initial post this week. In particular, an entire topic that caught my attention is called, Binge Free Challenge, and it is actually still live today - running for one week.

The goal was to have a binge-free week and what I find so interesting is the creation of normalcy around binging. This is a support forum, so the women do not want to binge and are working to not binge, but the women who slip and do binge are told to hang in there and start again tomorrow. What I guess I have a concern with is the support that is given is to try again tomorrow, but I am finding very little that suggests getting a doctor's help. Binge-eating is an eating disorder and I guess I am concerned with the creation reality through normalizing the behavior. I believe that the argument is that binge eating is just like any other part of a diet and you have to resist the urges in order to lose weight. But, again, the focus is on weight-loss rather than the unhealthy aspect of binging.

This reminds me of one of Jean Kilbourne's lecture/discussions for her book, Can't Buy My Love where she discusses the control of advertising to shape the way women think and feel. She argued that advertising normalizes binge eating, but in reality, a healthy eating pattern would not include binge eating at all.

I think that this forum discussion on binge eating encourages the argument that it is normal to want to binge and to slip up and binge, but if you want to lose weight, you have to control your binge-eating. Rather than questioning the urge to binge and encouraging a healthy mental attitude toward food, the chat forum continues to encourage the white-knuckling of avoidance and rewards a multi-day stint free from binging.

1 comment:

  1. The dissociation of binge-eating and health is something that I have never thought about. The argument here that binge-eating is not a disorder seems problematic, as you pointed out, since it does not really address the root of the issue. I wonder what role bias plays in this argument.

    ReplyDelete