Saturday, October 23, 2010

3FatChicks - Weight & Height Stats

Originally, I thought I would post about the forum asking "1200 Calories, way too much?". The woman who started the post was simply not losing weight with her 1200 calorie diet and was asking fellow posters whether she should go down to 900 calories. To my relief, nobody responded back that a 900 calorie diet sounded like a good idea. Instead, they began to attack pasta. The first poster outlined her typical day of food which consisted of two or three bowls of pasta. The fellow dieting posters all rallied and decided that the reason she wasn't losing weight was because she was eating too many carbs. So, now the woman is supposed to track her food and try to add in more protein and fat to trick her body back into losing weight.

It's all so complicated.

Another blog forum asks, "So many diets, which to choose?". Once inside the forum, everybody has a different opinion but they all have a general theme of, you won't know until you try one.

What I've been noticing in these chat forums are that many of the posters are putting little weight loss trackers supplied by the 3FatChicks website. The posters have a little tracker at the bottom of each post and then they have a star next to the part of the scale they are at currently. One woman has a smiley face as she gets closer and closer to her goal, unhappy faces at the beginning and then grimacing faces in the middle:



I then realized that many of the women posting have listed their height and weight next to their profile information. I am really disturbed by the obsession with the numbers on the scale. I feel like the 3FatChicks website makes it okay for people to obsess about their weight and focuses too heavily on reaching the desired number, rather than focusing on having a healthy relationship with food. I feel like the chat forums constantly associate dieting with health (i.e. Will diet coke make me lose weight?) when in actuality, a balanced diet with as little artificial products as possible is the healthiest way to lose weight.

I find the arguments made by fellow dieters troubling because these are not doctors or nutritionists giving advice and yet, the posters seem to be wholeheartedly accepting "facts." The bias that is clear in these posts, either the dieters who have lost or those that have not, does not mean that they have any idea of health.

1 comment:

  1. The issue of ethos that you mention at the end of your post seems to be an important part of the argument that you are observing. Even though these people are not doctors, their advice is taken like they are. It is because of the way in which the argument is conducted? The "space" in which it happens (online)? Or perhaps it is because of those numbers posted by each profile? Do the numbers give the impression that the individual knows something, since she is in the same situation? The progress meter may help to build ethos in a person if they are far from where they started.

    ReplyDelete