Thursday, November 11, 2010

The definition of marriage...

Continuing the discussion of Sister Wives, this story on abc.com called, "Sister Wives" Program Could Lead to Legal Trouble,, ultimately seems to be questioning the definition of marriage.

Kody Brown is only technically married to his first wife, however, he has been with at least one other wife for 16 years and his third wife for 15 years. And, he has recently added a fourth. The family calls each union a marriage, though the ceremonies for the last three have not been legally recognized by the state of Utah.

Greg Skordas, a local defense attourney in Salt Lake City, Utah, states “We normally do recognize common law marriage. Does the couple have children? Do they do things together as husband and wife? After a number of years, the court will recognize a common law marriage" (abc.com, September 2010).

If we call a long-term relationship, where a couple lives under the same roof and has children together, a common-law marriage, then the definition of marriage now extends to a whole variety of other couples (same sex, familial couples that live together and raise children, etc.). Though, law does not want to recognize many of these common-law unions as legal marriages, which would give rights to same-sex couples. So, this argument from definition is complicated from both sides of the case. The Brown family says that it is not a legal marriage, but a spiritual marriage, therefore, technically it is not a marriage that can land anybody in jail. Utah law says that non-legally bound unions can still be considered a "marriage" but perhaps only between heterosexual couples. And, for the Brown family to say that it is not a legal marriage so we are skirting the law, even though they truly feel that they are married, raises a few contridictions. If the couple perceives they are married, can they really be married? Is a spiritual marriage vs a legal marriage a legitimate distinction? And, if the family defines themselves as a polygamous family, then aren't they committing polygamy?

2 comments:

  1. I think that the distinction between civil/legal marriage and a spiritual marriage is really interesting. Some supporters of same sex marriage have argued that legally both heterosexual and homosexual couples should have the right to civil/legal marriages and the benefits that arise from it (taxes, medical rights, and so on) but that each individual religion should be able to make their own determination of who can be married. What you're really pointing out though is that this strategy also allows for another redefinition of marriage: that of a spiritual polygamy. I wonder if any of the critics of the show and/or of polygamous marriages have identified this line of argument?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Lara, just to see if I understand the arguments. So...the accused (the Brown family) are arguing that they are not behaving illegally because the husband is only legally married to one wife? What is the prosecution's argument? Also, I think it is interesting to think about common law marriages and agency. What happens if two people are considered to be married by the common law but do not want to be constrained by this definition? Are they still married in the eyes of the law or do they have to willingly accept the identification as married?

    ReplyDelete